Find · New mapJustKongNewcomer · 36★ Founding member·

Map of the Port of Saint Michael's

3840px-Atlas_Catalan_BnF_btv1b52509636n_Sheet_5.jpg1 Zoom in on the map
⇄It challenges · a placeThat the Prophet's tomb is in Mecca.
!
The claim
The Prophet's tomb is in Medina, not Mecca, according to this map.
⇄
It challenges · a place
That the Prophet's tomb is in Mecca.
✓ Confirmed by JustKong
Tags on this map · 1Tag something here

The picture: a walled city labelled ciutat de mecha (city of Mecca), with a gold coffin in a blue pool. A pilgrim kneels below it, and almedina (Medina) sits just above.

The text says, roughly: “Mecca. In this city is the ark [coffin] of Mafumet, prophet of the sarrayns, who come here on pilgrimage from all their lands… and having seen so precious a thing they say they are not worthy to see more, and they blind themselves out of reverence for Mafumet.”

Two errors in the map:

  • The Prophet’s tomb is in Medina, not Mecca.
  • The blinding story is a European legend.

The panel tells you what Christian Mallorca believed in 1375, not how Mecca really was.

10Map
SharedVerifyingVerifiedUsed as evidence
A website
Map factsUnverified · 0 of 3 checks
TitleAtlas Catalan BnF btv1b52509636n Sheet 5source page
MapmakerAbraham Cresquessource page
Year1375source page
PeriodZayyanidsworked out
ShowsPort of Saint Michael'syou
LanguageLatinon the map
Places namedLatinon the map
Held byBibliothèque nationale de Francesource page
Atlas or bookCatalan Atlassource page
Verify · 0 of 30 confirm it
Verify · 0 of 3
Help verify this find

Open the source, answer 4 quick questions. About 2 minutes.

Used as evidence in
Nothing yet. Bring it into a question as a finding:
Ask a question about this

You’ll sign in or create an account when you post. What you wrote is kept.

comments · 0