Example thread from the design phase — open for real findings.
36
ChallengeBaynaEditor · 1·
Treaty of Darin, article 6: what was actually promised?
The 1915 text is public. Finding #1 tables the six articles; two members have attached the National Archives scan. Needs 25 votes to enter the ranking.
Stage 1 of 5 · FindingsHow this thread reaches a published findinghow this works
1 · Findings
Anyone posts a point of view with evidence.
2 · Ranking vote
Needs 25 votes on the thread. Top 3 findings advance.
3 · Verification
Members check each finding's evidence, not whether they agree. Needs 15 checks, two-thirds must pass.
4 · Assembled
Verified findings are compiled into the page, in vote order, every contributor credited.
5 · Published
Live on the wiki and the timeline. Anyone can open a challenge, which reruns stages 3–5.
Grades describe the evidence, never a vote. A finding takes the grade of the evidence that establishes it; interpretation is always D. A · Quranic text · B · Material evidence · C · Dated document · D · Interpretation · E · Unverified